The SGP – Faulty by Design or Made Faulty by Politicians? An Assessment Based on a Simulation Model
By joining the European Monetary Union (the “EMU”), member countries lost the ability to use monetary policy as a tool for macroeconomic regulation. The attention was then focused on regulation of fiscal policy and Stability and Growth Pact (the “SGP”) was the instrument agreed upon. The states of the EMU have agreed to meet the 3% of GDP requirement for the maximum annual public budget deficit. Based on evolution of public debt in member countries, we can say that the SGP has failed as a tool for fiscal discipline. In this paper, we answer the question of whether the failure was due to the incorrect concept of the SGP or whether the development of the debt was affected more by arbitrary disrespect of the agreed rules. The two reasons mentioned above are interdependent. To separate them, we construct a dynamic model of EU countries’ public debt. By using real data, we simulate the potential values of public debt in a situation where the SGP rules have been respected in recent years. Comparing the results for the potential debt given by simulation of the model with the current real values, we are able to quantify the impact of non-compliance for each country. The initial results indicate that there are both EU states where non-compliance led to a negligible increase in public debt – up to 7% of GDP – and other states where this factor caused the growth of public debt by more than 30% of GDP.
AFONSO, A. (2005). Fiscal Sustainability: The Unpleasant European Case. Finanzarchiv. 61(1), pp. 19–44.
AFONSO, A., RAULT, C. (2010). What Do We Really Know about Fiscal Sustainability in the EU? A Panel Data Diagnostic. Review of World Economics. 145(4), pp. 731–755.
ALESINA, A., GIAVAZZI, F. (2002). Europe’s Destabilizing Stability Pact. Project Syndicate. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/ag8/English
BLANCHARD, O., CHOURAQUI, J.-C., HAGEMANN, R.P., SARTOR, N. (1990). The Sustainability of Fiscal Policy: New Answers to an Old Question. OECD Economic Studies. 15. Retrieved November 5, 2013, from http://www.oecd.org/eco/outlook/34288870.pdf
BUITER, W. (2006). The “Sense and Nonsense of Maastricht” Revisited: What Have we Learnt about Stabilization in EMU? Journal of Common Market Studies. 44(4), pp. 687–710.
BUTI, M., EIJFFINGER, S., FRANCO, D. (2003). Revisiting the Stability and Growth Pact: Grand Design or Internal Adjustment? European Economy – Economic Papers No. 180 (ISBN 92-894-4917-9).
BUTI, M., MARTINOT, B. (2000). Open Issues in the Implementation of the Stability and Growth Pact. National Institute Economic Review. 174, pp. 92–104.
CALMFORS, L. (2005). What Remains of the Stability Pact and What Next? SIEPS Reports, No. 8. Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies (ISBN 91-85129-31-3).
COLLIGNON, S. (2012). Fiscal Policy Rules and the Sustainability of Public Debt in Europe. International Economic Review [online]. 53(2), pp. 539–567.
COUDERT, V. (2013). On Currency Misalignments within the Euro Area. Review of International Economics. 21(1), pp. 35–48.
DE GRAUWE, P. (2003). The Stability and Growth Pact in Need of Reform. Centre for European Policy Studies. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http//www.econ.kuleuven.ac.be/ew/academic/intecon/Degrauwe/PDG-papers/Discussion_papers/Stability%20and%20Growth%20Pact%20CEPS%202003.pdf
DUWICQUET, V., MAZIER, J., SAADAOUI, J. (2013). Désajustement de change féderalisme budgétaire et redistribution: Comment s'ajuster en union monétaire. Revue de l'OFCE. 1(127), pp. 57–96.
ECOFIN (2005). Council’s Report on Improving the Implementation of the Stability and Growth Pact, 2005. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.eu2005.lu/en/actualites/documents_travail/2005/03/21stab/stab...
ECB (2004). Monthly Bulletin. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/mobu/mb200401en.pdf (ISSN 1725-2822).
ECB (2012). Monthly Bulletin. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/mobu/mb201204en.pdf
EUROPEAN COMMISSION (1997a). Council Regulation (EC) No. 1467/97 of 7 July 1997 on Speeding Up and Clarifying the Implementation of the Excessive Deficit Procedure. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:1997:209:0006...
EUROPEAN COMMISSION (1997b). Resolution of the European Council on the Stability and Growth Pact Amsterdam. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:31997Y0802%2...
EUROPEAN COMMISSION (2012). Treaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance Signed. European Council. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.european-council.europa.eu/home-page/highlights/treaty-on-sta...
EUROPEAN COMMISSION (2013). Making it Happen: The European Semester. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://ec.europa.eu/europe2020/making-it-happen/
EUROPEAN UNION LAW (2011). The Pact for the Euro: A Summary. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://eulaw.wordpress.com/2011/03/13/the-pact-for-the-euro-a-summary/
EUROSTAT (2013). The Main Factors Contributing to Changes in Government Debt Other than Government Deficits/Surpluses (Stock-Flow Adjustment). Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/cache/ITY_PUBLIC/STOCK_FLOW_2013_APR/EN...
FISCHER, J., JONUNG, L., LARCH, M. (2006). 101 Proposals to Reform the Stability and Growth Pact. Why So Many? A Survey. European Economy – Economic Papers, No. 267 (ISBN 92-79-03843-5).
HAUPTMEIER, S., SANCHEZ FUENTES, J., SCHUKNECHT, L. (2010). Towards Expenditure Rules and Fiscal Sanity in the Euro Area. European Central Bank working paper series. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/scpwps/ecbwp1266.pdf (ISSN 1725-2806).
IZÁK, V. (2009). Primary Balance, Public Debt and Fiscal Variables in Postsocialist Members of the European Union. Prague Economic Papers 2/2009.
SCHUKNECHT, L., MOUTOT, P., ROTHER, P., STARK, S. (2011). The Stability and Growth Pact: Crisis and Reform. European Central Bank occasional paper series, No. 129.
STOIAN, A. (2011). A Retrospective Approach on Assessing Fiscal Vulnerability: Empirical Evidence for Overindebted European Countries. Timisoara Journal of Economics. 4(3(15)), pp. 183–188.
STOIAN, A., ALVES, R. (2012). Can EU High Indebted Countries Manage to Fulﬁll Fiscal Sustainability? Some Evidence from the Solvency Constraint. FEP working papers. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://wps.fep.up.pt/wps/wp464.pdf
VAN DEN NOORD, P. (2010). Turning the Page? EU Fiscal Consolidation in the Wake of the Crisis. Empirica. 38(1), pp. 19–51.
VAN NIEUWENHUYZE, C. (2013). Debt, Assets and Imbalances in the Euro Area. Revue de l'OFCE. 1(127), pp. 123–152. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.cairn.info/revue-de-l-ofce-2013-1-page-123.htm
VON HAGEN, J., WOLFF, G.B. (2006). What Do Deficits Tell Us about Debt? Empirical Evidence on Creative Accounting with Fiscal Rules in the EU. Journal of Banking & Finance. 30(12), pp. 3259–3279.
WENZEL, H.-D., LACKENBAUER, J., BRÖSAMLE, K.J. (2004). Public Debt and the Future of the EU’s Stability and Growth Pact. Working paper no. 50. Germany: Bamberg University. Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.uni-bamberg.de/fileadmin/uni/fakultaeten/sowi_lehrstuehle/vwl...